Should welfare come with obligations?
Should someone receiving welfare benefits have duties in return?
- Yes, a few hours a week of community activity
- Yes, training or an active job search
- No, it's a right, not a favour
What's at stake: The debate pits two views of solidarity: an unconditional right, or an exchange of rights and duties.
The left's argument
Social protection is a right, not a favour: demanding something in return stigmatises.
The centre's argument
Ask for training or an active job search, rather than compulsory work.
The right's argument
Solidarity works both ways: some commitment is fair to those who pay for it.
And you, where do you stand?
Answer 30 situations like this one and find out where you stand, topic by topic.