Police violence: systemic or isolated cases?
Police violence…
- A systemic problem needing deep reform
- Isolated cases to be severely punished
- We criticise too much a police force doing a hard job
What's at stake: The debate pits two readings: the excesses of a system that needs reform, or individual faults in a high-risk job.
The left's argument
Repeated cases reveal a problem of training, oversight and sometimes discrimination.
The centre's argument
Punish every abuse, with investigations that are truly independent of the police.
The right's argument
Police officers face more violence. Misconduct exists, but it remains rare.
And you, where do you stand?
Answer 30 situations like this one and find out where you stand, topic by topic.